Poster for The Only Living Pickpocket in New York: a man in a long overcoat stands in front of the city skyline at dusk

It takes very little time to start worrying about Harry Lehman.

John Turturro plays him with the confidence of someone who knows his routine and the growing unease of someone discovering that it no longer works. Harry makes his living picking pockets in a New York where cash is becoming harder to find and the things people carry are increasingly difficult to sell. He has responsibilities at home, and very little room for a mistake.

Then he steals something from exactly the wrong person.

Noah Segan builds an excellent thriller from that collision. A valuable stolen item puts Harry under pressure to recover what he has already passed on, and the screenplay keeps finding ways to complicate his situation. The tension holds because every new development changes the choices available to a man we have already begun to care about.

The writing is particularly good at keeping us uncertain about where those choices will lead. There are turns that genuinely surprise, and the film sustains that uncertainty well into its final stretch. I kept trying to work out how Harry could get through it. The script gives you enough to think alongside him while leaving plenty of room to be wrong.

Turturro is the reason that involvement becomes so immediate. His versatility has been clear for years, but this role gives him an especially rich combination of resourcefulness, vulnerability and stubbornness. Harry is capable of reading people and making quick decisions. He is also tired, exposed and dependent on skills whose value is disappearing around him.

The performance makes those qualities coexist naturally. You can recognise a bad decision as he makes it and still understand the person making it. His circumstances become urgent without erasing his responsibility for them. By the time the danger escalates, the film has made it very difficult to watch him with any emotional distance.

Sam Levy’s photography is superb. Harry’s movement through New York gives the film much of its visual life, and the attention to his hands connects the images to the practical work of stealing. There is pleasure in watching someone carry out a familiar skill, even as we become increasingly anxious about what that skill might bring him.

There is also the pleasure of Steve Buscemi. His scenes with Turturro have an ease that gives their relationship history without requiring much explanation. The exchanges allow the film to breathe and deepen our sense of Harry’s place in the city. Buscemi makes his presence count.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York gets an enormous amount right: the tension, the photography, the turns in the screenplay and, above all, its central performance. The attachment to Harry keeps growing as his options narrow. Turturro gives us someone whose survival becomes a personal concern, and Segan knows how to keep that concern alive until the end.